MLB- More Betting
MLB player props today: Top Tuesday plays include Cade Horton [9/16/2025]
Get MLB player props today with projections for Tuesday's games.

Our MLB player props for Tuesday, September 16, 2025, are locked in, generated through groundbreaking simulations and high-tech machine learning.
These MLB player props are here today to enhance your betting strategy and feature players such as Cade Horton, Yanquiel Fernandez and Nathan Church.
Three of today's prop betting opportunities are listed below, with Dimers Pro members getting unlimited access to our full suite of prop picks and today's MLB pitcher projections.
Join Dimers Pro now to unlock our complete set of data-driven props and best bets.
List of MLB prop picks for Tuesday
While the MLB prop picks on this page for Tuesday are sorted by win probability, betting on likelihood alone means leaving money on the table.
Savvy bettors chase edge—not just probability—and the highest-edge picks are reserved for Dimers Pro users to give them the best shot at winning.
Cade Horton over 1.5 earned runs (-145)
- Probability: 66.3%
- Edge: 7.2%
- Game: Cubs vs. Pirates (6:40PM ET)
Our model has flagged a standout MLB prop for Tuesday's Cubs vs. Pirates matchup, focusing on CHI Cubs' Cade Horton. With a 66.3% chance of hitting, we suggest betting on Cade Horton over 1.5 earned runs at -145 odds, offering an edge of 7.2%.
Yanquiel Fernandez to get a hit (-125)
- Probability: 65.3%
- Edge: 9.8%
- Game: Marlins vs. Rockies (8:40PM ET)
Our model has identified another high-probability prop for Tuesday's MLB action, with Colorado's Yanquiel Fernandez in our sights in the Marlins-Rockies game. We recommend betting on Yanquiel Fernandez to get a hit with an edge of 9.8% at -125 odds.
Nathan Church to get a hit (-130)
- Probability: 65.2%
- Edge: 8.7%
- Game: Reds vs. Cardinals (7:45PM ET)
According to our analysis, another strong prop for today's MLB action focuses on St. Louis' Nathan Church in the Reds vs. Cardinals game. The recommended bet is Nathan Church to get a hit at -130 odds, with a 65.2% chance of hitting and an 8.7% edge.
MLB player prop picks: Tuesday, September 16, 2025
A quick summary of today’s top three props by probability according to our model as of 6:57PM ET:
Matchup | Prop | Odds | Probability | Edge |
---|---|---|---|---|
Cubs vs. Pirates | Cade Horton Over 1.5 Earned Runs | -145 @ BetMGM | 66.3% | 7.2% |
Marlins vs. Rockies | Yanquiel Fernandez To Get a Hit | -125 @ BetMGM | 65.3% | 9.8% |
Reds vs. Cardinals | Nathan Church To Get a Hit | -130 @ BetMGM | 65.2% | 8.7% |
Get unlimited access to our complete suite of prop picks by signing up for Dimers Pro.
Tuesday's MLB slate features a total of 294 MLB player props at the time of writing, all backed by real betting value.
Bet365 bonus code "DIMERS" — perfect for MLB prop betting
To make the most of Tuesday's prop picks—headlined by action on Cade Horton—check out the latest Bet365 bonus code "DIMERS" that secures $200 in bonus bets from a $5 bet — win or lose. Let's go!
More about MLB
The prop bets on this page are part of our MLB player props and MLB best bets series.
Stay updated with the latest MLB news, data-driven MLB predictions, MLB betting trends and World Series odds.
Conclusion
For September 16, 2025, our MLB prop bets are locked and loaded, featuring players like Cade Horton, Yanquiel Fernandez and Nathan Church. Powered by the latest data and cutting-edge simulations, these picks are here to make sure you're betting smarter, not harder.
With the help of AI and automation, this article delivers today's MLB prop bets and insights quickly and accurately, while human oversight ensures high editorial quality. Our predictions are based on current data to help you make informed decisions.
For additional resources and advice on responsible gambling, please call 1-800-GAMBLER.
Note: Clicking links to our sportsbook partners may earn us a referral fee. Learn about how we review products and services.