Bet these MLB Division winners after the All-Star Break
MLB is back from the All-Star Break and we've found a handful of division winners that the Dimers model says you should bet on.
The 2026 MLB season is getting back to action after the All-Star Break, and with about 70 games left to play for each team, we're looking at those who can make a move in the division races and push for the World Series.
By comparing Dimers' in-house probabilities for every team against the market odds and our preseason predictions we can spot which teams are being overpriced or undervalued at any given point in the season.
It's exactly how we found a huge +1300 Blue Jays AL East futures bet last season, and while in a different sport, precisely how we cashed a +9350 NFL division winner parlay this past season.
As we get back into MLB betting for the second half, let's look at the tightest division races and see which teams get some true betting value to make a run.
To see our daily, weekly and season-long MLB insights and futures updates, including these below, you'll need a Dimers Pro subscription - sign up for FREE to try Dimers Pro for 3 days.
Bet these teams MLB division winners after the All-Star Break
From current leaders to sub-.500 contenders, each of these teams is closer to a division title than the sportsbooks suggest.
New York Yankees win AL East (+125 on DraftKings)
Dimers AL East win probability: 56.3%
Dimers' fair odds: -128
This one stands alone as the only team above a 50% probability, and is just as much about the Yankees' fortunes as about fading a market that's overrating Tampa Bay's two-game cushion.
The Rays exit the break with the best record in the AL at 56-38, built off a modest +32 run differential and a dominant 35-15 home record, but the Yankees sit just three games back at 54-42 while holding the top AL Wild Card spot and riding a four-game win streak.
The Dimers model has the Rays at just 36.2% to win the division, well shy of what -130 implies, instead predicting the Yankees, who recently snapped a 4-14 funk, should see their prospects improve as injured players return.
Getting them at plus money to close a three-game deficit with Aaron Judge presumably returning down the stretch presents genuine value.
Chicago Cubs win NL Central (+500 on bet365)
Dimers NL Central win probability: 30.0%
Dimers' fair odds: +233
This is among Dimers' best division plays on the board, and the gap between our model and the market is stark.
Chicago sits five games back of red-hot Milwaukee (59-37) at 54-42, and the Cubs were just about the hottest team in baseball over the final month of the first half, going 20-8, even while battling pitching injuries all season.
St. Louis and Pittsburgh are also over .500, but are single-digit probability afterthoughts, and still, Dimers slots Chicago clearly behind Milwaukee as the second-most-likely winner at 30%.
But, with BetRivers pricing them at +500 against a fair line closer to +230, you're getting a massive edge on a mispriced underdog.
A 5-game gap can be overcome with a single winning streak and with 7 more head-to-head games in the schedule, that could make all the difference.
For some longer odds, Dimers also likes the Cubs' value in World Series and NL markets, though both of those require a path through the mighty Dodgers.
Twins to win AL Central (+950 on BetMGM)
Dimers AL Central win probability: 17.5%
Dimers' fair odds: +470
In the standings, the AL Central remains a genuine three-team scrum between the Guardians, White Sox and Twins, but at the sportsbooks, it's much different
At just 3 games back, the Twins get a 17.5% probability to win the AL Central. That's still third behind the Guardians (+100, 47.8%) and the White Sox (+200, 24.4%), but it's the odds discrepancy that puts Minnesota on the radar.
The best odds on BetMGM are +950, while Dimers' 17.5% implies fair value closer to +470, more than double the odds our model says should be offered. You can get an edge at most books, but even others have the Twins as short as +600, making this the biggest value play of the bunch.
Astros to win AL West (+650 on FanDuel)
Dimers AL West win probability: 15.7%
Dimers' fair odds: +536
Less of a longshot on the books, but the shortest probability by the Dimers model, we get a slim edge on the Astros to course-correct and win the AL West.
The AL West is as flat as any division in baseball right now, which is exactly the setup Dimers likes for a value play on Houston.
For a team that couldn't buy a win in April, only 2 games back in the division coming out of the break is a great place to be, regardless of personnel, which happens to include the league's second-ranked slugger, Yordan Alvarez, with 31 home runs.
The Astros have heated up of late on the back of f a roster that's gotten healthier, notably in their pitching staff. With three teams separated by a handful of games and Dimers' 15.7% (fair line of +536) against a market price of +650 presenting a clear value, we recommend taking a chance on a team that's been through the ringer once or twice before.
Responsible gambling
Remember to please gamble responsibly. If you sense that you're taking your luck too far, know when to call it quits and don't be afraid to seek assistance. Keep in mind that gambling is all about having a fantastic experience! If you or someone you know is grappling with gambling issues, reach out to 1-800-MY-RESET for crisis counseling and support.
Continue reading with Dimers Pro
Join now to unlock this article and get full access to our predictions and betting tools. Cancel anytime.
Dave Garofolo uses sophisticated AI-driven analytics to make predictions and evaluate player performances in the NBA, MLB, NFL, NHL, NCAAM, and PGA TOUR tournaments, crafting insightful game and prop previews.
