Blue Jackets vs. Islanders prediction, odds, pick for Nov. 17, 2026
Our Blue Jackets vs. Islanders predictions include win probabilities, the latest odds, and goal-scorer projections.

The New York Islanders are favored to beat the Columbus Blue Jackets at UBS Arena on Tuesday (7:00 PM ET), according to Dimers' NHL model.
Our Blue Jackets vs. Islanders prediction gives New York a 54.9% chance of winning, but the latest odds suggest there's betting value on Blue Jackets as the underdog.
Blue Jackets vs. Islanders key predictions
- Islanders win probability: 54.9%
- Blue Jackets win probability: 45.1%
- Blue Jackets +1.5 puck line: 67.7% cover probability
- Over 5.5 goals: 52.1% probability
Our NHL predictions estimate how many goals each team is likely to score, accounting for factors such as recent performance, shooting and save percentages, home-ice advantage, and rest.
We then calculate the probability of each team winning and covering the puck line, plus the chance the game goes over or under the total, and compare those probabilities with the latest odds to find betting value.
Blue Jackets vs. Islanders odds
Here are the best available prices across the moneyline, puck line, and total goals markets we track.
- Blue Jackets moneyline: +125 (theScore Bet)
- Islanders moneyline: 57¢ (Novig)
- Blue Jackets +1.5: 68¢ (Novig)
- Islanders -1.5: 34¢ (Novig)
- Over 5.5 goals: 53¢ (Novig)
- Under 5.5 goals: 48¢ (Novig)
Odds are subject to change and may vary by location.
Blue Jackets vs. Islanders pick: Blue Jackets ML (+125)
Our model makes the Islanders the more likely winner, but our best value bet is the Blue Jackets moneyline at +125 on ESPN Bet.
Those odds give Blue Jackets an implied win probability of 44.4%, while our model puts it at 45.1%.
That's a 0.6% edge (accounting for rounding), the biggest across the moneyline, puck line, and total goals markets.
Blue Jackets vs. Islanders goal-scorer predictions
Our NHL player props model simulates each matchup 10,000 times to estimate goal-scoring probabilities, factoring in expected player usage, lineup changes, opponent strength, and projected team goals.
Bo Horvat of the Islanders leads the anytime goal-scorer projections for Tuesday's game at 33.2%, ahead of teammate Victor Eklund (28.3%). Columbus's most likely goal-scorer, Adam Fantilli, is further back at 27.4%. Horvat also leads the first goal-scorer projections at 6.3%.
Most likely anytime goal-scorers
- Bo Horvat (Islanders): 33.2%
- Victor Eklund (Islanders): 28.3%
- Adam Fantilli (Blue Jackets): 27.4%
- Matthew Knies (Blue Jackets): 25.7%
- Matthew Schaefer (Islanders): 25.1%
First goal-scorer predictions
- Bo Horvat (Islanders): 6.3%
- Victor Eklund (Islanders): 5.9%
- Adam Fantilli (Blue Jackets): 5.4%
- Matthew Knies (Blue Jackets): 5.2%
- Mathieu Olivier (Blue Jackets): 5.1%
These are model probabilities, not betting recommendations. Compare projections with available prices to assess potential value.
Get every Blue Jackets vs. Islanders prediction with Dimers Pro
Dimers Pro members get full access to our Blue Jackets vs. Islanders predictions, including:
- Best bets across the moneyline, puck line, and total goals markets
- Full anytime and first goal-scorer probabilities for players on both teams
- Player prop edges for anytime goal-scorer, first goal-scorer, shots on goal, points, and assists markets
Blue Jackets vs. Islanders game details
- Matchup: Columbus Blue Jackets vs. NY Islanders
- Date: Tuesday, November 17, 2026
- Puck drop: 7:00 PM ET
- Venue: UBS Arena
About this prediction
This preview uses predictions from our NHL models, presented through a template written by our editorial team. Matchup details fill in automatically.
Predictions are estimates, not guarantees, and can change as new information comes in, such as injury news or starting goaltender confirmations. Learn how our predictions work.
Dimers encourages responsible gambling.


